You find yourself in a conversation where someone dismisses everything religious. He or she argues that every religious system in the world is nothing but a variation on a single hollow theme. How do you respond to someone who maintains that all religions are the same?
One useful approach to this generalization is to ask a question or two. You might respond by asking, “Can you tell me how Christianity and Islam agree on the crucifixion of Jesus?” Christianity teaches that Jesus was crucified, buried, and rose from the dead. In 1 Corinthians 15:14 this is the truth on which Christianity either stands or falls. Islam teaches that Jesus was not crucified at all.
You might ask, “Does Hinduism or Buddhism teach that God is personal? Do they teach that God is external to that which he created?” Pantheistic systems declare that God is within all that he created, but Christianity teaches he is external to it. Pantheistic religion claims that God is impersonal. Christianity declares he is personal.
You might ask, “Does Christianity worship one God or thousands of Gods?” Hinduism embraces the idea of tens of thousands of deities, where Christianity is rigorously monotheistic.
You might ask, “Where does the Koran indicate that Allah has a son?” The Koran repudiates the idea that God can exist in the form of three persons, as Christianity maintains.
The point of the questions is that the object of worship is very different in each case.
Someone might argue that all religions are the same because they use similar words. You might ask, “Is the government of Russia the same as the government of the United States?” Both declare themselves to be republics, but they define the word in completely different ways. In our recent political conversations some define patriotism as a willingness to fight in the armed forces to defend freedom. Others define patriotism as a willingness to pay increasingly higher taxes to the government. Common words do not guarantee shared beliefs.
Another argument is that religions are identical because they have similar components. There are churches or temples. There is music and ritual. But again similar structures do not indicate similar beliefs. A company that produces bicycles may have many of the same structures of a company that makes computers. But a bicycle is not a computer. An Internet company that markets houses may use some of the same concepts as a company that markets pornography, but the two are not therefore identical in purpose or intent.
The differences in the core concepts of the nature of man, the world, and eternity are so striking that it takes a great deal of imagination to label them as one.